| The Return of a Millennial
Social Movement
By William Bole
Ever since Seattle erupted into a free-trade
fighting zone during the World Trade Organization's 1999 meeting, the very
scheduling of a global economic gathering has become a provocation to activists
worldwide. What happened suddenly in Seattle has transmigrated into rituals
of resistance
like that enacted in Quebec City at the 34-nation
Summit of the Americas, in April. Whether these rites have helped make
the global economy more sacred or less profane is disputable. They have
at least demonstrated that the party of globalization has a potent opposition,
or perhaps that economic globalization itself has matured into a two-party
system.
The opposition party is scattered and wide.
You could call it a big church, and indeed quite probably the most phenomenal
piece of it is a largely faith-driven movement of protestors with their
own rituals. They probably wouldn't whack down a chain-link fence like
the one erected to keep
out demonstrators in Quebec City, but they
love putting on chains to symbolize the bondage of poor nations. They don't
toss Molotov cocktails, as black-masked anarchists did in Seattle two years
ago, but they did burn a laptop computer outside a rich-nation summit in
Okinawa last summer.
These are debt campaigners, who collected the
world's largest petition signed by over 24 million supporters of debt cancellation
for the most desperately poor countries. More than that, they dragged rich
nations into pledging more international debt relief than anyone could
have imagined a few years ago. And they did so while intoning obscure verses
from the Hebrew Scriptures calling for debt forgiveness every "seven times
seven" years, among other social deeds aimed at restoring economic equilibrium.
Now, the debt-relief forces, having been animated
by the biblical tradition of the Jubilee Year, are arrayed for a new engagement,
possibly on the wider stage of global finance and trade.
While Quebec City was this year's Mecca of
global resistance, for debt relievers it will be Genoa, Italy. That is
where fleets of them are expected to come and call for an ultimate round
of sweeping debt cancellation when the G-8 meets there July 20-23, with
provisional member Russia added to the rich seven. Last year in Okinawa,
Jubilee activists were furious when the G-8 deemed the "digital divide"
a more respectable item of deliberation than poor-nation debt. So in a
heretical gesture against the digerati, they torched a laptop.
Campaigners want the World Bank and International
Monetary Fund, basically controlled by the seven, to wipe clean the debt
slate of the worst-off countries. G-8 leaders say they and their institutions
have forgiven quite enough debt -- up to one-half of that owed to them
by 22 hard-pressed countries. Actually the more realistic figure is a bit
under one-third, which represents the effective cut in debt-service payments.
At any rate, even after those 22 countries
get all of the debt relief coming to them under the Heavily Indebted Poor
Countries initiative, they will still put out more in debt payments than
they spend on healthcare or education, on average.
How much steam the Jubilee debt-relief engine
has left in it is hard to judge. It is, after all, a millennial movement.
And the millennial theme is a quickly "diminishing asset," as readily acknowledged
by Adrian Lovett of Drop the Debt, a London-based successor to the Jubilee
2000 campaign.
World Bank and IMF officials argue the Third
World debt is now sustainable, meaning it no longer hinders development
and social wellbeing. Of course, they said that in the mid-1990s when the
debt burden was clearly catastrophic. Still, the load has been lightened
and admittedly there is much else to do, like beating back the internal
demons of corruption and strife in many a debt-stricken land.
Beyond Genoa, what comes of Jubilee intensity
in a post-Jubilee time? Does it follow the letter of Leviticus, the prime
biblical text calling for absolute debt forgiveness? Or is that a case
of financial fundamentalism, as some intimate? Do the millennial forces
regroup on the broader battlefield of globalization? How?
Much of this is still to be revealed. In Rome,
Pope John Paul II clearly feels the debt crusade isn't over, though the
Holy See is also looking beyond Genoa to complex questions such as free
and fair trade.
At least one thing is clear: debt-relief disciples
haven't been afraid to ride this once-arcane policy debate, this affair
of international finance, onto some stretch of transcendental terrain,
some ground of ultimate concern.
It is hard to think of a squishier sentiment
from any hard-nosed "realpolitik" perspective, yet equally hard to picture
a spunkier start for a far-reaching faith-rooted movement of global engagement,
if that is to come.
William Bole is an associate fellow of the
Woodstock Theological Center at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C.
A longer version of this article appears in the June 18-25 issue of America
magazine. |